Stevie’s Pizza Menu

Stevie’s Pizza in Matawan, NJ, is quickly becoming a beloved local gem for pizza lovers. Their menu highlights a variety of expertly crafted pizzas, from the classic Plain Slice to the flavorful Grandma’s Square Pizza, each boasting a perfectly thin, crisp crust topped with fresh, high-quality ingredients. The sauce strikes an ideal balance of sweet and tangy, perfectly complementing the buttery mozzarella and aromatic fresh basil, elevating every bite to comfort food perfection.

Beyond pizza, Stevie’s offers specialty slices like Margherita, buffalo, and cheesesteak, each carrying bold, fresh flavors that impress. Wings here are a must-try—crispy, well-seasoned, and incredibly fresh, showcasing the kitchen’s attention to detail. The friendly, welcoming staff and owners add warmth to the experience, making every visit feel personal and inviting.

Stevie’s Pizza isn’t just about great food; it’s about creating a community hub where authentic flavors and genuine hospitality meet. A must-visit for anyone craving top-tier pizza in Northern Monmouth County.